Sell My Car

Used Cars for Sale in Bay Shore, NY

Browse 2,185 used cars, trucks and SUVs for sale in Bay Shore, NY from 4 local dealerships. Median asking price $37,695, median 3 miles.

2,185vehicles
4dealerships
$5,995–$244,075price range
$37,695median price
3median miles

2,185 vehicles · page 1 of 46

Frequently asked questions

How many used cars are for sale in Bay Shore, NY?
AutosXchange currently lists 2,185 vehicles in Bay Shore, NY from 4 dealerships.
What is the average price of a used car in Bay Shore, NY?
The median dealer-advertised price is $37,695, ranging from $5,995 to $244,075.
Are there used cars under $20,000 in Bay Shore, NY?
Yes. 59 of the 2,185 vehicles listed in Bay Shore, NY are priced under $20,000.
What are the most common makes for sale in Bay Shore, NY?
The most-listed makes are Nissan (1,269), Chevrolet (510), Mazda (203).

Dealer listings are supplied by each dealership from its own website and refreshed as inventory changes; prices are dealer-advertised asking prices, so confirm availability, fees and final price with the selling dealer. Listings marked "Private seller" are submitted by the car's owner and reviewed by AutosXchange; AutosXchange does not inspect private-party vehicles.

AutosXchange Intel

Who removed and who added cars in Bay Shore, NY

Last 7 days, from listing tracking of every dealer. Removed = not advertised anywhere since (not always a sale); cars moved to another dealer and bulk feed changes are not counted.

Removed the most

  1. Nissan of Bayshore — 72 removed (2026 Nissan Rogue ×31…)
  2. Atlantic Chevrolet — 33 removed (2027 Chevrolet Equinox ×4…)

All 105 cars removed in Bay Shore, NY, last 7 days →

Added the most

  1. Nissan of Bayshore — 90 added (2027 Nissan Rogue ×36…)
  2. Atlantic Chevrolet — 17 added (2027 Chevrolet Traverse ×3…)

All 107 cars added in Bay Shore, NY, last 7 days →

Dealer activity in Bay Shore, NY · Heatmap