2021 Subaru Crosstrek Limited
$4,759 less than this car
- 126,938 mi
- AWD
- Automatic
- SUV
Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 5 mi away
58,426 miles · suv · Price dropped $1,574

Please contact us to set up your test drive appointment! Appointments are from 9am-7pm Monday - Friday and 9am-5pm on Saturday. 845-374-0085 Pricing reflects vehicle in its current condition. Please go over entire vehicle prior to committing to purchase. Please verify all information by speaking with a representative. All vehicles come with 1 key minimum. Please be sure to visit Frank Siena's Auto Sales Inc. online at www.franksienaautosales.com to see more pictures of this vehicle or call us at 845-374-0085 today to schedule your test drive!! Always be sure to tell your salesman, you saw the vehicle online with the SPECIAL internet pricing to receive our no haggle price! All of our vehicles come fully serviced and warrantied! If the vehicle doesn't pass our extensive safety check, we won't sell it. Nationwide shipping available!!
Dealer-provided information may change. Confirm availability, price, vehicle condition, taxes and fees with the selling dealership.
Among the lowest-priced · 88% of 8 similar listings ask more than this car.
How we calculate market value: comparable cars for sale now plus their last listed prices.
Price tracked by AutosXchange since Nov 5, 2026. 1 price change at this dealership: $23,498 → $21,924 (−$1,574).
Market activity: Subaru Crosstrek prices in the Northeast: 11.8% of listings cut in 48 hours
AutosXchange Intel Hub: Price changes for this model in New York · This model in the Intel Hub · Market movers in New York
Dealer-advertised asking prices as observed by AutosXchange (data as of Nov 13); earlier listings at other dealerships are shown by state only. Source: AutosXchange Intel Hub, autos-xchange.com/market.
Same 2020–2022 Crosstrek Limited · used · any miles · within 50 miles of New Hampton, New York. All 8 comparable cars for sale, nearest first.
$4,759 less than this car
Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 5 mi away
$2,400 more than this car
Ramsey Subaru · Ramsey, NJ · 26 mi away
$3,541 more than this car
Subaru White Plains · Elmsford, NY · 38 mi away
$2,553 more than this car
Subaru of Englewood · Englewood, NJ · 41 mi away
$3,068 more than this car
Subaru of Englewood · Englewood, NJ · 41 mi away
$1,070 more than this car
Subaru World of Hackettstown · Hackettstown, NJ · 42 mi away
$3,075 more than this car
Newark Auto Sports Co. · Newark, NJ · 48 mi away
$539 more than this car
Volvo Cars Manhattan · New York, NY · 48 mi away
2021 Subaru Crosstrek Limited126,938 miles · Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 5 mi away$17,165$4,759 less than this car
2021 Subaru Crosstrek Limited33,594 miles · Ramsey Subaru · Ramsey, NJ · 26 mi away$24,324$2,400 more than this car
2020 Subaru Crosstrek Limited22,030 miles · Subaru White Plains · Elmsford, NY · 38 mi away$25,465$3,541 more than this car
2022 Subaru Crosstrek Limited29,870 miles · Subaru of Englewood · Englewood, NJ · 41 mi away$24,477$2,553 more than this car
2020 Subaru Crosstrek Limited24,457 miles · Subaru of Englewood · Englewood, NJ · 41 mi away$24,992$3,068 more than this car
2022 Subaru Crosstrek Limited CVT60,907 miles · Subaru World of Hackettstown · Hackettstown, NJ · 42 mi away$22,994$1,070 more than this car
2021 Subaru Crosstrek Limited64,187 miles · Newark Auto Sports Co. · Newark, NJ · 48 mi away$24,999$3,075 more than this car
2022 Subaru Crosstrek Limited SUV28,559 miles · Volvo Cars Manhattan · New York, NY · 48 mi away$22,463$539 more than this carAll years and trims. Nearest first.
Frank Siena's Auto Sales Inc. · New Hampton, NY · 0 mi away
Frank Siena's Auto Sales Inc. · New Hampton, NY · 0 mi away
Nissan of Middletown · New Hampton, NY · 0 mi away
Frank Siena's Auto Sales Inc. · New Hampton, NY · 0 mi away
2021 Subaru Crosstrek Premium CVT54,255 miles · Frank Siena's Auto Sales Inc. · New Hampton, NY · 0 mi away$21,600
2023 Subaru Crosstrek Sport CVT15,314 miles · Frank Siena's Auto Sales Inc. · New Hampton, NY · 0 mi away$25,998
2023 Subaru Crosstrek Sport34,166 miles · Nissan of Middletown · New Hampton, NY · 0 mi away$23,599
2024 Subaru Crosstrek Premium AWD70,236 miles · Frank Siena's Auto Sales Inc. · New Hampton, NY · 0 mi away$22,271