2024 Subaru Forester Premium
$1,500 less than this car
- 49,377 mi
- AWD
- Automatic
- SUV
Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away
36,309 miles · suv

The 2024 Subaru Forester Premium is a reliable and efficient vehicle, boasting an impressive 2.5 liter 4 cylinder engine with fuel injection. This car has been driven 36,266 miles and offers a fuel economy of 26 mpg in the city and 33 mpg on the highway. It also comes with a 5 out of 5 star crash test rating for added safety and peace of mind. Furthermore, this car features hill start assist and full time four wheel drive to make your driving experience smoother and more enjoyable. With its combination of power, efficiency, and safety, the 2024 Subaru Forester Premium is an excellent choice for any driver looking for a dependable automobile. At Johnstons Subaru, our goal is to exceed your expectations at all times. The moment your walk into our showroom, which features the latest Subaru Impreza, Forester, Legacy, Outback and WRX models available, we intend to help you find a new or used car you'll love. Johnstons Subaru, located at 3480 Route 6 in Middletown, NY, is your premier retailer of new and used Subaru vehicles. Our dedicated sales staff and top-trained technicians are here to make your auto shopping experience fun.
Dealer-provided information may change. Confirm availability, price, vehicle condition, taxes and fees with the selling dealership.
In the typical middle range · 55% of 22 similar listings ask more than this car.
How we calculate market value: comparable cars for sale now plus their last listed prices.
Price tracked by AutosXchange since Nov 5, 2026. No price change at this dealership since Nov 5 ($27,165).0 price changes at this dealership: $27,165 → $27,165.
AutosXchange Intel Hub: Price changes for this model in New York · This model in the Intel Hub · Market movers in New York
Dealer-advertised asking prices as observed by AutosXchange (data as of Nov 11); earlier listings at other dealerships are shown by state only. Source: AutosXchange Intel Hub, autos-xchange.com/market.
Same 2024 Forester Premium · used · any miles · within 50 miles of Middletown, New York. Showing the 12 nearest of 22 comparable cars for sale, nearest first.
$1,500 less than this car
Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away
$172 less than this car
Frank Siena's Auto Sales Inc. · New Hampton, NY · 5 mi away
$2,490 less than this car
Healey Hyundai · Fishkill, NY · 31 mi away
$659 more than this car
Ramsey Subaru · Ramsey, NJ · 32 mi away
$1,234 more than this car
Ramsey Subaru · Ramsey, NJ · 32 mi away
$598 more than this car
Curry Subaru · Cortlandt Manor, NY · 32 mi away
$1,179 less than this car
Paul Miller Subaru · Parsippany, NJ · 41 mi away
$1,005 more than this car
Prestige Subaru · Pleasantville, NY · 42 mi away
$1,434 less than this car
Subaru White Plains · Elmsford, NY · 43 mi away
$1,152 less than this car
Subaru White Plains · Elmsford, NY · 43 mi away
$226 less than this car
Subaru White Plains · Elmsford, NY · 43 mi away
$1,000 more than this car
Brewster Subaru · Brewster, NY · 46 mi away
2024 Subaru Forester Premium49,377 miles · Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away$25,665$1,500 less than this car
2024 Subaru Forester Premium AWD43,922 miles · Frank Siena's Auto Sales Inc. · New Hampton, NY · 5 mi away$26,993$172 less than this car
2024 Subaru Forester Premium36,755 miles · Healey Hyundai · Fishkill, NY · 31 mi away$24,675$2,490 less than this car
2024 Subaru Forester Premium24,994 miles · Ramsey Subaru · Ramsey, NJ · 32 mi away$27,824$659 more than this car
2024 Subaru Forester Premium22,734 miles · Ramsey Subaru · Ramsey, NJ · 32 mi away$28,399$1,234 more than this car
2024 Subaru Forester Premium30,378 miles · Curry Subaru · Cortlandt Manor, NY · 32 mi away$27,763$598 more than this car
2024 Subaru Forester Premium28,880 miles · Paul Miller Subaru · Parsippany, NJ · 41 mi away$25,986$1,179 less than this car
2024 Subaru Forester Premium40,317 miles · Prestige Subaru · Pleasantville, NY · 42 mi away$28,170$1,005 more than this car
2024 Subaru Forester Premium26,625 miles · Subaru White Plains · Elmsford, NY · 43 mi away$25,731$1,434 less than this car
2024 Subaru Forester Premium34,969 miles · Subaru White Plains · Elmsford, NY · 43 mi away$26,013$1,152 less than this car
2024 Subaru Forester Premium21,817 miles · Subaru White Plains · Elmsford, NY · 43 mi away$26,939$226 less than this car
2024 Subaru Forester Premium22,388 miles · Brewster Subaru · Brewster, NY · 46 mi away$28,165$1,000 more than this carAll years and trims. Nearest first.
Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away
Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away
Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away
Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away
Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away
Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away
Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away
Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away
2024 Subaru Forester Touring62,137 miles · Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away$27,665
2024 Subaru Forester Sport45,247 miles · Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away$26,165
2024 Subaru Forester Limited31,284 miles · Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away$29,665
2024 Subaru Forester Wilderness51,979 miles · Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away$29,165
2025 Subaru Forester Base17,625 miles · Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away$28,165
2025 Subaru Forester Sport5,324 miles · Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away$28,165
2025 Subaru Forester Premium24,414 miles · Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away$31,165
2025 Subaru Forester Base7,518 miles · Johnstons Subaru · Middletown, NY · 0 mi away$31,165